Recently we were asked a question about having two people play the same character. (It might have been a mixup, and by the sounds of it the game was oversubscribed.)
Our answer was that while it was tricky, it was doable – particularly with the character she had chosen.
What we recommended was to make the characters twins.
To do this:
- Give each player the full character pack, and explain that they are twins. (They can have the same name badge if you like – you could say that they look so alike that people can’t tell them apart.)
- Tell the twins that they can work together or not, as they prefer.
- Announce that the characters are twins that at the beginning of the game so that everyone understands what’s going on.
- Don’t make any other changes – so don’t double up on (say) items that they might be looking for. Instead they will both be searching for that same item, and it either of them finds it, that counts as a joint success in the goal if they are working together (or a success for one and a failure for the other if not!)
In sides with distinct sides, creating a twin can unbalance things, but in this case it didn’t matter.
If you like the idea of trying this, here are a few things to consider:
- It should be sensible for the character to be a twin – so we wouldn’t recommend twinning a parent, or anyone in a romantic relationship, or the Captain of a ship. That wouldn’t make sense.
- We wouldn’t recommend twinning the murderer (!).
- They shouldn’t have any unique items.
And of course, we don’t recommend doing this unless you absolutely have to – use all the characters (and free extra characters) first!
Note – we’ve not tested this – let us know if you try it out!
Pingback: Adding 20 players to Hollywood Lies | Freeform Games murder mystery blog