Can AI help you host a murder mystery party?

Playing A Most Scandalous Murder

Hosting one of our murder mystery games is great fun, but it can also be a little daunting, particularly if you’ve never hosted one before.

There’s quite a lot to keep track of. You need to know how the game works, who the characters are, what they’re trying to achieve, and what to do when players ask unexpected questions.

And they will ask unexpected questions.

Fortunately, there’s a new tool that might make hosting a little easier: Google’s Gemini Notebook (previously NotebookLM).

We’ve been experimenting with it at Freeform Games, and we’ve also asked some of our playtesters to try it out.

Here’s what we discovered.

What is Gemini Notebook?

Gemini Notebook is an AI-powered research assistant from Google. Unlike a general-purpose AI chatbot, it’s designed to answer questions using documents that you upload.

And that’s what makes it potentially useful for hosting a murder mystery party.

You can upload your murder mystery game materials into Gemini Notebook and then ask it questions about the game. Rather than searching through dozens of pages of character backgrounds, rules and other documents, you can simply ask a question and get an answer.

For example:

  • “Who knows that Professor Blackwood was having an affair?”
  • “Which characters have a reason to dislike the victim?”
  • “What happens if a character tries to steal an item?”
  • “Who starts the game with the silver necklace?”
  • “What am I supposed to do if someone is murdered during the game?”

Gemini Notebook can search the uploaded materials and give you an answer, often with references to the relevant parts of the documents.

Think of it as a searchable assistant that has read your murder mystery game and can help you find information when you need it.

Playing Way out West in a post-apocalyptic setting

How can Gemini Notebook help you prepare?

One of the biggest jobs when hosting a Freeform Games murder mystery is getting familiar with the game.

You don’t need to memorise everything, and you certainly don’t need to read every character booklet. But you do need to understand how the game works and be comfortable answering questions.

Gemini Notebook can help in several ways.

Getting to grips with the plot: Ask it to explain the main storylines, identify important relationships between characters, or summarise particular parts of the game. (This can be especially useful if your murder mystery has a large cast.)

Finding information quickly: Perhaps you’re preparing the character envelopes and can’t remember who starts with a particular item. Rather than searching through the game materials, you can ask Gemini Notebook.

Checking your understanding: If you’re uncertain about a rule or how a particular event is supposed to work, you can ask for clarification before the party starts. (It will provide links to the relevant documents, so you can check yourself.)

How can it help during the party?

Our murder mysteries aren’t scripted, round-based games. Once the party starts, your guests can talk to whoever they want, investigate whatever interests them, and pursue their own objectives.

That freedom is what makes our games fun, but it also means that players sometimes do things you weren’t expecting.

You might be asked whether a particular character knows a secret, whether an item can be used in a certain way, or what happens when someone attempts something unusual.

Normally, you’d have to look through the game materials or make a ruling on the spot.

With Gemini Notebook, you can ask the question on your phone or tablet and potentially get an answer in seconds.

Of course, it won’t always have an answer. Some questions involve situations that aren’t covered by the game materials, and you’ll still need to use your judgement.

But for questions where the answer is somewhere in the game, it could save you quite a bit of searching.

Playing A Most Scandalous Murder

What did our playtesters think?

We asked playtesters to experiment with Gemini Notebook while playtesting our games. Their experiences were encouraging, although not everyone found it equally useful.

Bethany Baudhuin was enthusiastic:

“I did use notebook and that super helped me find answers quickly.”

Linda Steele experimented with Gemini Notebook on both her computer and tablet. Although she didn’t end up using it much during the party, she could see the potential:

“But in hindsight, when there was a prop that I did not have in my “envelope stuffing” list, I could have used it to quickly determine who the item belonged to and did not think of that at the time.”

Linda also pointed out that she still preferred working with pencil and paper, and that AI tools aren’t always reliable, even when supplied with accurate source material.

David Gourevitch tried asking Gemini Notebook questions during his game and found its answers accurate, although he didn’t feel it added much to his particular hosting experience:

“I’d say it may be useful for someone that was nervous about running the game, or someone who didn’t have much time to prepare.”

That seems fair to us. Experienced hosts may already be comfortable making quick decisions, while first-time hosts might appreciate having an extra source of reassurance.

How to set up Gemini Notebook for your murder mystery

Getting started is fairly straightforward.

  1. Visit Gemini Notebook and sign in with your Google account.
  2. Create a new notebook for your murder mystery party.
  3. Upload the game materials you’ve downloaded from Freeform Games. Include the host instructions, character booklets and other relevant documents.
  4. Try asking a few questions about the game to see how well it works.
  5. Keep the notebook available on your phone, tablet or computer during the party.

It’s worth experimenting before your guests arrive. That way, you’ll know how to ask questions and how useful the answers are likely to be.

You could even test it with a few questions you already know the answers to.

One important point: Your notebook may contain all the game’s secrets, including information that individual players shouldn’t know. Keep it for your use rather than sharing it with your guests!

Playing our Davy Jones' Locker murder mystery game.

Can you trust the answers?

Mostly, perhaps. Completely, no.

Gemini Notebook is designed to work from the documents you provide, which should make it better suited to this task than asking a general AI chatbot that hasn’t seen the game.

But AI can still make mistakes.

Linda found this when experimenting with Gemini Notebook for other games:

“I had not tried Notebook before then at all, and since then I have been using it for gaming etc and found it to be mostly reliable but not always, even using only accurate sources such as the official wiki it still sometimes gets simple facts wrong.”

So we wouldn’t recommend treating Gemini Notebook as an infallible authority. (Although Steve notes that when he’s used it, Gemini Notebook has been pretty accurate when it sticks to the sources you upload.)

If an answer seems surprising or particularly important, check it against the original game materials. Gemini Notebook’s source references can help you do that.

And remember that a Freeform Games murder mystery doesn’t require you to get every ruling exactly right. As host, you’re there to help everyone have a good time. If something unexpected happens, making a sensible decision is often better than spending several minutes searching for the perfect answer.

What happens to the materials you upload?

You might be concerned about uploading your murder mystery game to an AI service.

The good news is that Google states that the documents you upload to Gemini Notebook are not used to train its AI models. Your game materials are used to answer your questions, not to teach Google’s AI about the game.

There is one caveat: if you submit feedback about an answer (using the thumbs-up or thumbs-down buttons), Google may review the associated content, including your uploaded documents, and use it to improve its services.

So, if you’re using Gemini Notebook to help host one of our games, we’d recommend not submitting feedback. You can read more in Google’s explanation of how Gemini Notebook protects your data.

Playing our A Fatal Theory murder mystery game.

Is Gemini Notebook worth using?

We think it’s worth a try, particularly if you’re hosting your first Freeform Games murder mystery or running a game with a large cast.

It won’t replace reading the host instructions, preparing the game properly or using your judgement during play.

And if you’re an experienced host who prefers paper notes and making decisions on the fly, you might not need it at all.

But having an assistant that can search through your game materials and help answer questions could make hosting less stressful.

Best of all, you can experiment with Gemini Notebook before your party and decide whether it works for you.

Have you tried using AI to help host a murder mystery party? We’d love to hear how you got on, particularly if you’ve discovered a clever use we haven’t thought of.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Written by Steve Hatherley

Category: Party Tips
Tags:
19 November 2026

Recent posts

Post-apocalyptic Way out West

Post-apocalyptic Way out West

Hello, Freeform Games team! I’d like to share how I hosted my first parlor LARP party in Saratov, Russia, for 20 participants.

Costume ideas for The Deadly Library

Costume ideas for The Deadly Library

The Deadly Library is a murder mystery party set in 1887, in the magnificent private library of the eccentric Martin Alexandria. Guests include wealthy society figures, scholars, journalists, detectives and fashionable Londoners, all gathered to hear an important announcement. But before the evening is over, there will be murder!

What Our Clients Say
313 reviews